
You fall on a broken stair tread at an apartment complex and report it to the office. The office says the vendor handles repairs. The vendor says the owner never approved the work order. A month later, two insurance companies are writing to you, each explaining politely that the other one is responsible, while your knee still hurts and nobody has paid a single bill.
Why Two Companies Show Up in One Claim
Almost no apartment owner in Florida actually swings a hammer. Ownership sits with one company, daily operations sit with a management firm, and the physical work goes to vendors who handle landscaping, pools, pest control, or general repairs. Injured tenants usually learn this structure only after they report the fall, which is often when they contact Meldon Law Firm and start reading the lease closely for the first time.
That layering is ordinary business practice rather than a trick. It turns into a problem only after someone gets hurt, because each company carries its own insurer and its own reason to point further down the chain. Nobody in that chain has any obligation to explain the structure to you, and most leasing offices cannot explain it anyway.
What the Landlord Owes No Matter Who Does the Work
State law puts the upkeep obligation on the landlord directly. Florida Statutes § 83.51 says the landlord, at all times during the tenancy,y must comply with applicable building, housing, and health codes, or, where none apply, keep floors, steps, porches, exterior walls, foundations, and other structural components in good repair. Nothing in that section moves the obligation onto whoever the landlord hires to do the work. While those duties can be altered in writing for a single-family home or duplex, apartment buildings stay squarely covered.
- Code compliance – applicable building, housing, and health code requirements.
- Structural parts – floors, steps, porches, and exterior walls in repair.
- Common areas – clean and safe condition in multi-unit buildings.
- Locks and keys – required in anything larger than a duplex.
Where the Maintenance Company’s Own Duty Begins
A vendor carries its own responsibility separate from the owner’s. When a crew takes control of a stairwell, a pool deck, or a walkway to do work there, it owes ordinary care to the people who use that space, and what a management company handles usually includes coordinating exactly those contractors. A hazard the crew creates, or one it was hired to fix and left alone, belongs to the crew.
The two duties overlap rather than cancel each other. A landlord who never inspected and a vendor who patched a step badly can both be negligent in the same fall, which is why these claims so often end up with two or three named defendants instead of one.
How Florida Splits the Blame Between Them
Florida does not let you collect everything from whichever company has the deepest pockets. Florida Statutes § 768.81 directs a court to enter judgment against each party based on that party’s own percentage of fault rather than on joint and several liability. A defendant assigned 30 percent of the fault pays 30 percent of the damages and nothing more, even when the other company turns out to be uninsured or out of business.
That rule has a sharp edge worth knowing about. The same section lets a defendant shift blame onto a company that was never sued, provided it affirmatively pleads that nonparty’s fault and proves it at trial. If the landlord convinces a jury that an unnamed vendor caused 60 percent of your injury, that share simply disappears from your recovery.
Why You Identify Everyone Early
Deadlines close while people are still arguing about who was responsible under Florida Statutes § 95.11(4)(a); you generally have two years from the date of injury to file a negligence lawsuit over a fall occurring on or after March 24, 2023. Learning that a vendor existed in month twenty-three of a two-year clock helps nobody, least of all you.
- Your lease – names the owner and the management company.
- Work orders – show which vendor handled that specific repair.
- Incident report – records who responded and who employed them.
- Photos – capture vendor trucks, uniforms, and posted signage.
Who Pays Gets Settled Long After Who Fell
The companies involved will spend months sorting out their contracts, their indemnity clauses, and their insurance towers. None of that is your job, and none of it changes what happened on the stairs. What falls to you is naming every company that touched that area before the deadline runs, because a defendant left off the lawsuit becomes a convenient place for everyone else to send the blame. Ask for the maintenance records in writing, keep the names you are given, and treat every company in the chain as a possible answer rather than assuming the sign in the leasing office is the whole story.



