Best medical malpractice attorneys in Scranton, PA

0
20

A bad outcome after surgery or a missed diagnosis does not automatically mean malpractice.

Medicine carries real risk, and Pennsylvania treats an injury as malpractice only when care fell below the accepted standard and that failure caused measurable harm.

Finding out which one happened to you is the job of a good lawyer. The five Scranton firms below all handle plaintiff-side malpractice cases, but they differ in trial experience, in-house medical resources and how clearly they explain fees.

Key Takeaways

  • Our top pick pairs a USD 10 million verdict, the largest medical malpractice verdict in Luzerne County history, with a board-certified trial advocate at the helm.
  • Munley Law offers round-the-clock contact and says it advances all case costs.
  • Foley Law Firm says it is the only Northeastern Pennsylvania firm with a full-time, board-certified physician on staff.
  • Fellerman & Ciarimboli includes a nurse attorney with more than 20 years of nursing experience on its malpractice team.
  • McDonald & MacGregor charges no upfront, hourly or flat fees.
  • Pennsylvania generally allows two years to file and requires a Certificate of Merit within 60 days of filing a complaint.

How We Picked

We reviewed each firm’s own medical malpractice page, attorney biographies and published fee terms.

Every result and credential below comes from the firm’s own site, so treat them as self-reported and confirm anything important during a consultation.

We weighed four things: a Scranton presence, identifiable malpractice and trial experience, access to medical expertise and clear initial-cost terms.

This list is not exhaustive, and it is not a bar association endorsement.

1. Scartelli Olszewski

Scartelli Olszewski has fought for victims of medical negligence throughout Scranton, Lackawanna County and Northeastern Pennsylvania since 2001. The firm works from 411 Jefferson Avenue in Scranton and a second office in Wilkes-Barre.

Pros

  • More than 100 years of combined legal experience across its attorneys
  • Founder Melissa A. Scartelli is an NBTA Board Certified Civil Trial Advocate
  • Managing Partner Peter Paul Olszewski, Jr. is a former Luzerne County District Attorney and Court of Common Pleas Judge
  • A USD 10 million jury verdict for a young man harmed by a misdiagnosis and delayed treatment
  • A USD 1.5 million verdict, including punitive damages, against an orthopedic surgeon for an unnecessary amputation

Cons

  • Two offices, so confirm whether your meetings will be in Scranton or Wilkes-Barre

Why We Picked It

This firm earns the top spot for a rare mix of board-certified trial leadership, a former judge’s courtroom perspective and a county-record verdict. That depth matters because malpractice cases often turn on expert testimony and trial readiness.

Fees

The firm advances all case expenses and collects its fee only from a settlement or verdict. If there is no recovery, it says you owe nothing.

2. Munley Law

Munley Law has practiced in Scranton since 1959 and handles malpractice claims from its Penn Avenue office. It is a larger firm with offices across Pennsylvania and one in Binghamton, New York.

Pros

  • Says its team is available 24/7
  • Marion Munley was named Best Lawyers’ Lawyer of the Year for Medical Malpractice Law (Plaintiffs) in Northeastern Pennsylvania in 2021 and 2023
  • Caroline Munley was named one of the NTLA’s Top 25 Medical Malpractice Trial Lawyers in Pennsylvania
  • Reports malpractice results of USD 5 million, USD 4.35 million and USD 3.5 million
  • Meets with medical professionals during its investigation to pinpoint where care fell short

Cons

  • Many offices and attorneys, so ask who will personally handle your case

Why We Picked It

We included Munley for readers who want a long-established firm that is easy to reach. Its page lays out a clear path from free consultation to investigation, settlement talks and trial if needed.

Fees

Munley says it advances all case costs and works on contingency, so you pay nothing unless it wins. Ask how advanced costs are repaid from any recovery.

3. Foley Law Firm

Founded in 1979, Foley Law Firm handles birth injury, hospital error, misdiagnosis and other malpractice claims. It works from offices in Scranton and Stroudsburg.

Pros

  • Says it is the only Northeastern Pennsylvania firm with a full-time, board-certified physician on staff
  • Says four of its Scranton malpractice lawyers have been named Pennsylvania Super Lawyers
  • Says its lawyers are available 24/7
  • Offers home visits when necessary
  • Its lawyers work with the on-staff physician to gauge the full financial burden of an injury

Cons

  • Its malpractice page does not publish the contingency percentage

Why We Picked It

We included Foley for readers who want medical insight built into the firm. Ask how its physician would review your records during the early evaluation.

Fees

Foley offers free consultations and works on contingency, collecting a percentage of any award or settlement. You pay nothing unless it recovers compensation for you.

Image suggestion: A patient and attorney reviewing medical records together at a desk, with a stethoscope and file folders in view. Alt text: Attorney reviewing a patient’s medical records during a malpractice consultation in Scranton

4. Fellerman & Ciarimboli

Fellerman & Ciarimboli handles Scranton malpractice claims from its Adams Avenue office. The firm also serves clients from Kingston, Stroudsburg, Berwick, Plymouth Meeting and Philadelphia.

Pros

  • Malpractice team led by Managing Senior Attorney Molly Dempsey Clark, who has nearly 30 years of experience
  • Nurse attorney Melanie Fellerman spent more than 20 years as a registered nurse
  • Melanie Fellerman began her nursing career in labor and delivery, a useful background for birth injury claims
  • Staff includes a legal nurse consultant
  • Handles surgical errors, misdiagnosis, birth injury, hospital negligence and medication errors

Cons

  • The pages we reviewed do not spell out fee terms

Why We Picked It

We included this firm for readers who value a nurse attorney’s clinical perspective on their records. Ask who will handle your matter, since its team works across several offices.

Fees

The firm offers free consultations. Ask for the contingency percentage and expense terms in writing before you sign.

5. McDonald & MacGregor

McDonald & MacGregor handles malpractice cases from its Scranton office at 220 Penn Avenue. It serves clients across ten Northeastern Pennsylvania counties, from Lackawanna and Luzerne to Monroe and Pike.

Pros

  • Reports 93 years of combined legal experience
  • Works with respected specialists in relevant medical fields to support claims
  • Says it is ready to take cases to trial when needed
  • Says trial lawyer organizations seek its attorneys to teach fellow lawyers
  • Handles a wide range of claims, from emergency room errors to lab result mistakes

Cons

  • One office, so ask about meeting options if you live farther from Scranton

Why We Picked It

We included McDonald & MacGregor for readers who prefer a smaller firm with plain fee terms. Its page also stresses that every case is different, which is a useful reminder not to compare firms by verdict size alone.

Fees

The firm works on contingency with nothing upfront and no hourly or flat fees. It says it explains all terms clearly when you first call.

What Pennsylvania Requires Before a Case Moves Forward

Pennsylvania gives most patients two years to file a malpractice lawsuit, generally counted from when they knew or reasonably should have known about the injury. Claims involving minors or government facilities follow different deadlines, so check your own timeline early.

Before a case can proceed, Rule 1042.3 requires a Certificate of Merit within 60 days of filing the complaint. A licensed professional in the same or a similar specialty must support it, which is why a firm’s access to medical experts matters so much.

Pennsylvania does not cap compensatory damages in malpractice cases. Punitive damages against an individual physician are capped at 200% of compensatory damages.

Image suggestion: The exterior of a county courthouse on a clear day, with steps leading to the main entrance. Alt text: County courthouse in Northeastern Pennsylvania where malpractice cases are filed

Questions to Ask Before You Sign

Ask each firm who will handle your matter day to day and how medical experts will review your records. Request the contingency percentage and expense terms in writing, since attorney fees and case costs are separate.

A serious injury can also affect your work and income while a case plays out. It helps to understand what losing your job can mean while managing a health condition, then share those losses with your lawyer early.

Conclusion

Our top pick leads this list for its county-record verdict, board-certified trial leadership and clear expense terms.

Munley suits readers who want round-the-clock access, Foley stands out for its in-house physician, Fellerman & Ciarimboli brings a nurse attorney’s perspective and McDonald & MacGregor offers a smaller-firm option.

Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. This article is general information, not legal advice, so speak with a licensed Pennsylvania attorney about your situation.

FAQ

How long do I have to file a medical malpractice claim in Pennsylvania?

Most claims must be filed within two years of when you knew or reasonably should have known about the injury. Different rules can apply to minors and to claims against government facilities.

What is a Certificate of Merit?

It is a filing supported by a licensed professional in the same or a similar specialty, confirming the care likely fell below accepted standards. It is due within 60 days of filing the complaint.

Does Pennsylvania cap malpractice damages?

There is no cap on economic or non-economic damages. Punitive damages against an individual physician are capped at 200% of compensatory damages.

What does “no fee unless we win” cover?

It usually refers to attorney fees, which may not include case expenses such as expert reviews and records. Ask whether the firm advances costs and what you owe if there is no recovery.